top of page

Reflection Piece on OER: Openness in Whose Interest?

9 hours ago
3 min read

By: Dr. Brittany Castonguay November 2026 #OER


In 2019, Dr. Maha Bali wrote a reflective piece from her recent experience at an Open Educational Resources (OER) conference. Her experience at this event echoed situations she encountered throughout her career, and the concerns she felt then are still felt today.  Yet, something changed. During one of the breakout sessions, she said “Permissions are paternalistic. To focus on openness as permissions is paternalistic” (Bali, 2019). For context, Bali was reflecting on the term openness, which is often associated with free access to it’s users. Yet it was the second and tertiary associations that made her stop and realize that when an author or organization gives its audience ‘permission’ to use an open resource, there is generally a string tied to that relationship, making the resource less ‘open’ and more of a conditional reference. 


According to Bali (2019), permissions are usually tied to copyright regulations and act as a permission slip that restricts how users can access copyrighted material. She believes this type of permission is counterintuitive to the original meaning and spirit of OERs, which are meant to be an agreement from the author that highlights their work’s accessibility.


AI-generated image of learners of different capabilities all engaging with the same learning material
Accessibility does not mean paying extra for the same or similar experience.

Accessibility is the term that should be used versus permission. Permission is a variation of the original copyright restrictions. Very authoritative, with little delegation.  On the other hand, accessibility ensures all populations have the same degree of access regardless of outside resources.


Accessibility is the wheelchair ramp at a popular location.
Accessibility is closed captions on the screen, highlighting what someone hard of hearing may not be able to understand.
Accessibility is also a sensory legend throughout a museum, letting guests know which exhibits may cause stress or triggers and giving them advance notice of how to engage with the attraction.
Accessibility does not mean paying extra for the same or similar experience, and that is the key difference Bali was attempting to reinforce in her piece, Openness in Whose Interest. 

Let us take a moment to pause here and consider permissions versus accessibility. Like Bali, we are not saying copyright is wrong, and all materials should be Open Access. On the contrary. As an author, instructional designer, and entrepreneur, I want my work to be protected. I am also empowered to decide which publications I permit others to use, like my book, and what I grant Open Access to, like my professional articles. I believe Bali was trying to strike a balance between the old cliché, “talking out the side of your mouth.” 


Do you feel OERs have a place in business?

  • Yes

  • No

  • Unsure

  • Yes, if there is a process that is truly Open Access


As creators, we can make the professional decision to educate, entertain, and engage our audience without a permission slip on a string. Yes, I recognize that in the world of sales, there is always a string or a hook or a pitch. That is how I make a living. Do not confuse business and Open Access. The two rarely integrate without conflict. Accessibility is giving everyone, even those without adequate resources, the same access to information.


Those who promote OERs or stand behind Open Access should consider those materials accessible items without a permission slip. That is why copyright supports permissions for proprietary protection, and Creative Commons supports accessibility without a preponderance of resources. The two are very distinct, and I hope that SHRI will maintain the understandable difference between the two throughout its operation under me, Dr. C. 


License


CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International

  


Comments


bottom of page